Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
Afghanistan election campaign posters
Afghan women pass by electoral posters of presidential and provincial council candidates in Kabul. Photograph: S. Sabawoon/EPA
Afghan women pass by electoral posters of presidential and provincial council candidates in Kabul. Photograph: S. Sabawoon/EPA

A catalogue of errors that cost Karzai victory

This article is more than 14 years old
Afghanistan's Electoral Complaints Commission has pointed to a host of polling flaws in the country's August ballot

Documents released today by Afghanistan's Electoral Complaints Commission showed:

A mosque in Khak I Safeid, in Farah, was one of more than 30 polling stations where 100% of the valid votes went to one candidate. One vote did go to another candidate, but it was marked as invalid.

Some polling stations showed competing vote-rigging. At Faselahcompound in Zarghoon Shaher, Paktika province, all the votes showed identical markings, none of the ballots was folded, and all 600 votes went to one candidate – but they were recorded as votes for someone else.

Turnout was suspiciously high at a number of stations. At a polling station at a religious school in Ghazni province, 1,055 votes with 100% uniform markings were cast in a polling station that served an estimated 1,400 people.

At a number of stations, several tactics were used to rig the vote. At Mirajan House, in Lashkar Gah, Helmand province, 75% of the papers showed uniform markings, none of the ballots was folded and some were placed in the wrong bundles and counted for other candidates; and a unusually high number of women were declared to have cast their vote.

In almost a third of the sample (92 polling stations), 100% of the papers had uniform markings. Another 69 polling stations recorded 75% of the ballots showing uniform markings.

In 41 polling stations, all ballot papers were unfolded.

The commission was asked only to provide "clear and convincing evidence of fraud". This meant that, even where 25% of the ballots showed uniform markings, the commission judged results from those stations as "valid".

Most viewed

Most viewed