Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to key eventsSkip to navigation

Syria crisis: Divisons among opposition as heavy fighting is reported in Damascus - Monday 5 November

This article is more than 11 years old
SNC balks at initiative which would dilute its influence
Peace envoy calls for new UN security council resolution
Heavy fighting in Damascus
Bomb blasts in Bahrain kill two
 Updated 
Mon 5 Nov 2012 10.45 ESTFirst published on Mon 5 Nov 2012 11.00 EST
Syria family internally displaced
A Syrian family who fled the violence in their village, set up a fire inside their tent at a camp in the Syrian village of Atma, near the Turkish border with Syria, Sunday, 4 November, 2012. Photograph: Khalil Hamra/AP Photograph: Khalil Hamra/AP
A Syrian family who fled the violence in their village, set up a fire inside their tent at a camp in the Syrian village of Atma, near the Turkish border with Syria, Sunday, 4 November, 2012. Photograph: Khalil Hamra/AP Photograph: Khalil Hamra/AP

Live feed

Summary

Syria

A new initiative backed by western powers to create a unified Syrian opposition appears to be in jeopardy of collapsing. A western diplomat told the BBC it was "falling apart" and Burhan Ghalioun, former leader of the SNC, which would see its influence diluted in the new grouping, described it as "dead". Another opposition group, the Local Coordination Committees, said "interventions in the affairs of our revolution, as stated in Hillary Clinton's remarks, are unwelcome". But prominent Syrian dissident Riad Seif, proposer of the Syrian National Initiative, expressed confidence that it would pass.

Opposition Activists have reported heavy fighting between rebels and government troops backed by Palestinian fighters in the capital Damascus. One group claimed that 23 people have been killed in the last 24 hours in the Palestinian refugee camp of Yarmouk, including seven when a mortar - which both sides blamed on the other - landed on a minibus. An activist told AP regime forces weer backed by the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine General Command.

Eleven people have been killed and 55 injured, including women and children, by a car bomb in a loyalist are of Mezzeh, Damascus, state media reported. Activists claim the Free Syrian Army said it planted the bomb and was targeting shabiha - pro-Assad thugs - in the area.

A suicide car bombing has killed at least 50 members of the Syrian security forces in Hama province, the UK-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said. Syrian state media put the death toll from the explosion in al-Ziyara at two (both civilians) and said 10 others were injured.

An air strike has killed more than 20 rebel fighters in Harem, in Idlib, the UK-based Syrian Observatory of Human Rights claims. It said a rebel leader in the town was seriously injured and believed to be dead.

The UN-Arab League envoy to Syria, Lakhdar Brahimi, has called for a new UN security council resolution to formalise an declaration adopted in Geneva in June, which called for a transitional administration but did not specify what role, if any, Assad would The initiative came after Brahimi met Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrovin Cairo yesterday. Brahimi said:

It is important that the Geneva Declaration be turned into a resolution from the security council to gain the power to enable it to become an applicable political project.

Al-Jazeera reported that Lavrov dismissed the need for a resolution, saying “some countries which participated in Geneva don't speak with the government but only with the opposition and encourage them to fight till victory and this has very negative implications”.

Japan is to host international talks in late November aimed at widening sanctions against Syria, it said today.Existing sanctions include freezing assets of the Syrian president and military leaders and an embargo on oil and arms trade with Syria.

Bahrain

Eleven dead in Mezzeh

State news agency Sana says 11 people have been killed and tens injured by a car bomb, which opposition activists claimed was planted by the Free Syrian Army targeting shabiha (pro-Assad thugs). From Sana:

Terrorists on Monday detonated an explosive device planted under a car in Mezzeh Jabal 86 area in Damascus, killing 11 citizens and injuring tens, including women and children.

A source at al-Muwasat hospital told Sana that it received the bodies of eight martyrs killed in the bombing and 31 injured people who are currently receiving treatment.

A source in Yousef al-Azmeh hospital said that the hospital received the bodies of three martyrs and 24 injured people, most of them critically injured.

Sana's correspondent who visited the bombing site said the explosion caused significant damage to the area which is heavily populated, and that a large number of cars and shops were destroyed and infrastructure and utilities were also damaged.

A handout picture released by the Syrian Arab News Agency ) shows Syrians inspecting the site of an explosion in the Mezzeh district of the capital Damascus on 5 November, 2012. Photograph: AFP/Getty Images Photograph: -/AFP/Getty Images

UK condemns Bahrain bombs

Foreign office minister Alistair Burt said: 

The UK strongly condemns the planting of improvised explosive devices in the Gudaibiya and Adliya areas of Bahrain this morning that resulted in the deaths of two civilians and seriously injured another. I offer my sincere condolences to all those affected.
 
There is no place in Bahraini society for any such acts of violence and all political societies in Bahrain should condemn the use of violence unequivocally. All parties should urgently enter into a constructive dialogue, without pre-conditions, to resolve ongoing tensions.

Meanwhile, Global Voices rounds up scepticism on Twitter about the bombs.

'New initiative is dead' - former SNC head

Burhan Ghalioun says the new Syrian National Initiative, backed by western powers to create a coherent opposition, is dead. But Riad Seif, the man leading the initiative, remains bullish about it, al-Jazeera's Hashem Ahelbarra tweets.

Former SNC chief Burhan Ghalioun: The new initiative is dead, impractical, the west must respect the will of the Syrian people

— hashem ahelbarra (@hashemahel) November 5, 2012

Riad Seif:my initiative will pass, I have the backing of many SNC members,soon we will form an interim government inside Syria

— hashem ahelbarra (@hashemahel) November 5, 2012

Car bomb reported in Damascus

Syrian TV is reporting an explosion in a loyalist area of Mezzeh, Damascus. TV footage (WARNING: graphic) shows a decapitated corpse being carried away. An activist group said via Skype:

FSA claimed responsibility for the blast that targeted a group of shabiha.

Electricity and communications cut off in parts of Mazzeh after explosion in the predominantly loyalist 86 area.#Damascus #Syria

— NMSyria (@NMSyria) November 5, 2012

site of The explosion, in Mezzeh 86 “@50u5: انفجار في حي المزة 86 في العاصمة #دمشق. #سوريا twitter.com/50u5/status/26…

— The 47th (@THE_47th) November 5, 2012

Air strike kills 20 rebel fighters, activist group says

An air strike has killed 20 rebel fighters in Harem, in Idlib, the UK-based Syrian Observatory of Human Rights claims.

More than 20 rebel fighters were killed by a fighter jet air-strike on the town of Harem, a rebel leader in the town was also seriously injured and is thought to be dead. The rebels are now bombarding the al-Tarem neighbourhood of Harem, which is considered the regime and pro-regime stronghold in the town.

'30 killed in Palestinian refugee camp'

AFP, citing Palestinian sources, reports that 30 people have been killed in 24 hours in the Yarmouk Palestinian refugee camp, south of Damascus, including seven when mortar landed on a minibus. Both sides are blaming the other for the minibus attack. From AFP:

“All night through to Monday, the residents heard deafening sounds of shelling, but this morning there are many people in the streets, the shops are open and traffic is normal,” a resident told reporters on condition of anonymity.

The day before, 24 people were killed when at least 10 shells fell on a southern part of the camp, according to a Facebook page called “Yarmuk Camp News” run by local residents, which listed the names of the victims.

'Suicide bombing kills 50'

 A suicide car bombing has killed at least 50 members of the Syrian security forces in Hama province, the UK-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said. It said:

At least 50 regular soldiers were killed when a suicide bomber from the [al-Qaida inspired] al-Nusra front detonated a car bomb next to a regime checkpoint in the al-Ziyara village, in Sahl al-Ghab (Ghab plains). Activists from the area reported that the operation was in coordination with other armed rebel groups.

Summary

Syria

An initiative backed by western powers to create a unified Syrian opposition appears to be in jeopardy with a western diplomat telling the BBC it was "falling apart". The Syrian National Council, the most prominent opposition group at present, has yet to say whether it will join the new Syrian National Initiative, which will see its influence diluted. In the meantime it has voted to broaden its membership to include more activists and political groups from inside the country - thereby answering some of the criticisms that have led western powers to back the new initiative. Another opposition group, the Local Coordination Committees, said "interventions in the affairs of our revolution, as stated in Hillary Clinton's remarks, are unwelcome".

Opposition Activists have reported heavy fighting between rebels and government troops backed by Palestinian fighters in the capital Damascus. The fighting is said to concentrated in the southern neighborhood of Tadamon and the outskirts of the Palestinian refugee camp of Yarmouk. An activist told AP regime forces were backed by the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine General Command. Five people were killed when a rocket or mortar landed near a minibus in the Yarmouk camp. Both sides blamed each other for the attack.

The UN-Arab League envoy to Syria, Lakhdar Brahimi, has called for a new UN security council resolution to formalise an declaration adopted in Geneva in June, which called for a transitional administration but did not specify what role, if any, Assad would The initiative came after Brahimi met the Russian foreign minister, Sergei Lavrov, in Cairo yesterday. Brahimi said:

It is important that the Geneva Declaration be turned into a resolution from the security council to gain the power to enable it to become an applicable political project.

Al Jazeera reported that Lavrov dismissed the need for a resolution, saying “some countries which participated in Geneva don't speak with the government but only with the opposition and encourage them to fight till victory and this has very negative implications”.

Japan is to host international talks in late November aimed at widening sanctions against Syria, it said today. Existing sanctions include freezing assets of the Syrian president and military leaders and an embargo on oil and arms trade with Syria.

Bahrain

State media: 'Terrorists to blame for minibus deaths'

Sana reports that deaths in the Yarmouk Palestinian refugee camp blamed by opposition activists on the regime's forces, were in fact inflicted by fighters opposed to President Assad:

Five people were martyred including three children and a woman on Monday when terrorists targeted a mini-bus of public transportation with a mortar shell in Thalathen street (thirty street) in al-Yarmouk Camp, Damascus.

An official source in Damascus Hospital said that bodies of a women and three children were transferred to the hospital in addition to five injured, one of them is in a critical condition, adding that the injured are getting the suitable care.

On the other hand, Palestine Hospital received a martyrs' body, in addition to five injured people due to the terrorist act.

Minibus passengers reportedly killed in Damascus

A rocket fell near a minibus in the the Palestinian refugee camp of Yarmouk, killing at least five civilians and wounded others, activists say. The UK-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said three children and a woman were killed. Another activist group said via Skype that seven people were killed in total. A video (WARNING: graphic) has been posted of the minibus.

Heavy fighting has been reported on the outskirts of Yarmouk.

Opposition suspicious about Bahrain bombing

The interior ministry has blamed the five blasts that killed two people on "terrorist acts".

Opposition politician Matar Matar of Shia party al-Wefaq told Reuters he doubted opposition activists were behind the attacks, noting that leading Shia clerics had called on followers to avoid escalating the conflict with the government. He said:

This incident is strange - why would anyone target workers? I'm worried that police and military are losing control of their units or it is (preparation) before declaring martial law.

Maryam al-Khawaja, acting head of the Bahrain Centre for Human Rights, told al-Akhbar:

As always, we condemn all acts of violence and call for an independent investigation into the bombings. There has been so much lying that we cannot trust anything this government says.

Bahraini policemen search for evidence at the scene of an explosion that killed an Asian man in Manama, Monday, 5 November, 2012. A series of bomb blasts in Bahrain's capital killed at least two people, authorities said. Photograph: Hasan Jamali/AP Photograph: Hasan Jamali/AP

'Rebels can't finish what they've started'

The Guardian's Martin Chulov has been tweeting reflections from his week in Aleppo.

Some reflections from another week in #Aleppo. 1/ Rebels can't finish what they've started. AQ groups alone in offering help.

— Martin Chulov (@martinchulov) November 5, 2012

2/ In #Aleppo area, home-grown AQ group Jabhat al-Nasraf around 800-strong. Foreign AQ group, al-Muhajarim has 500+ members #Syria

— Martin Chulov (@martinchulov) November 5, 2012

3/ Regime airforce flying higher, but still dominant. Our car targeted by cluster bomb dropped from a jet. Missed by 20 metres #Syria

— Martin Chulov (@martinchulov) November 5, 2012

4/ Rebels have held recent gains in Kurdish areas, but they're not meaningful. Frontlines barely shifted in past 2 months #Syria

— Martin Chulov (@martinchulov) November 5, 2012

5/#Aleppo seems more reconciled to its war within. Shops have opened. Buildings crumbling by the day. People in for long haul #Syria

— Martin Chulov (@martinchulov) November 5, 2012

No secret US-Russia talks over Syria

Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrov says there have been no secret talks with US about regime change in Syria. Russian state owned news agency Ria Novosti quotes Lavrov as saying:

We never hold secret discussions with anyone over the fate of a third-party country, and there was no secret discussion with the US or with anyone else about Bashar al-Assad.

In other comments today, to an Egyptian newspaper, Lavrov said Moscow is supplying arms to Syria under Soviet-era commitments meant for defence against external threats, not to support Assad. He told Ahram:

We do not side with any faction in Syria's internal battle. As for the Russian-Syrian technical military cooperation, it aims to support Syria's defence capabilities in the face of external political threat, and not to back Bashar al-Assad ...

It was the Soviet Union that supplied Syria with main weapons but at present we are in the process of finalising the implementation of our commitments which are linked primarily to the supply of some air defence systems. These military exports are of a defensive nature and do not conflict with international treaties.

Heavy fighting reported in Damascus

Activists are reporting heavy fighting between rebels and government troops backed by Palestinian fighters in the capital Damascus. From AP:

Rami Abdul-Rahman, who heads the Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, says the fighting is concentrated in the southern neighborhood of Tadamon and the outskirts of the Palestinian refugee camp of Yarmouk.

Damascus-based activist Abu Qais al-Shami told the Associated Press via Skype that the fighting began last night and went on continuously into Monday. He said regime forces are backed by the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine General Command led by Ahmed Jibril, a staunch supporter of President Bashar al-Assad.

The Local Co-ordination Committees says:

Severe clashes were reported between the Free Syrian Army and the regime's army in Tadamon neighbourhood and Yarmouk camp with machine guns. Severe artillery shelling was also reported in Tadamon neighborhood and Yalda.

This video purports to show the effects of shelling in Tadamon overnight.

Riyad Hijab: 'Bashar thinks he can settle this militarily'

In an interview with the Telegraph, Riyad Hijab, the former Syrian prime minister, claims that Bashar al-Assad has no interest in a peaceful resolution to the crisis (thanks to sjxt btl for highlighting this). Hijab said:

Bashar really thinks that he can settle this militarily … Bashar used to be scared of the international community – he was really worried that they would impose a no-fly zone over Syria. But then he tested the waters, and pushed and pushed and nothing happened. Now he can run air strikes and drop cluster bombs on his own population … My brief was to lead a national reconciliation government. But in our first meeting Bashar made it clear that this was a cover. He called us his 'war cabinet'.

LCC: 'Interventions in our revolution unwelcome'

One of the most influential Syrian opposition groups, the Local Co-ordination Committees, has released a statement on the political representation of the revolution. It says a unified opposition leadership is a matter of urgency. The LCC rejects foreign intervention "in the affairs of our revolution" but at the same time criticises the international community for not supporting the Syrian people and rebels.

It is no longer acceptable, under any pretext, to continue with the absence of a unified and effective political leadership for the revolution. All political parties must come together as quickly as possible to reach the proper political representation of the revolution …

Any formation of a new political entity must aim to represent the revolution and prioritise securing organised military support for the rebels and for relief efforts, despite personal loyalties and interests …

We clearly announce that interventions in the affairs of our revolution, as stated in Hillary Clinton's remarks, are unwelcome. It is on the international community to reconsider its defeatist policy against supporting the Syrian people and the rebels, which has lengthened the age of the regime and has extended the time for Syrians to be killed, increasing the complexity of the crisis and ultimately leading to extremism as a reaction.

Syrian National Council to broaden base

The Syrian National Council, has voted to broaden its membership to include more activists and political groups from inside the country, an organiser told AP.

Anas Abdah, an organizer of an SNC conference in Doha, says a majority of 222 delegates approved the additions, nearly doubling the size of the group's general assembly to some 420.

The vote comes as an alternative opposition grouping, the Syrian National Initiative, in which the SNC would have a lesser role is being backed by the US and others to create a more representative leadership.

Syrian regime opponent Abdulbasit Sieda (centre) talks with fellow participants ahead of the general assembly of the Syrian National Council meeting in Doha on 4 November 2012. Photograph: Faisal al-Tamimi/AFP/Getty Images Photograph: FAISAL AL-TAMIMI/AFP/Getty Images

Bombs in Bahrain kill two

Five homemade bombs have exploded in the Bahraini capital Manama killing two Asian men, the ministry of interior (MOI) says. A third man was seriously injured. The MOI report says:

An initial investigation has revealed that a bomb exploded when one of the deceased men kicked the device in Qudaibiya. He died at the scene. The second man was injured in an explosion near the Awal Cinema in Manama and was pronounced dead at the hospital. An explosion in Adliya seriously injured the third man who is an Asian cleaner. 

The MOI has advised people "not to touch strange objects".

Bahrain TV has broadcast footage of the victims (WARNING: graphic).

The apparently co-ordinated explosions point to escalating levels of violence by government opponents in the nearly 21-month uprising against the Gulf nation's western-backed rulers. Most of the violence directed at the government has taken place away from authorised marches and protests but last week Bahrain banned all opposition rallies, prompting concern from the international community. More than 55 people have been killed in Bahrain's unrest.

'Clinton's effort to build Syrian government in exile seems doomed'

That's the opinion of Joshua Landis on Syria Comment. He writes:

Washington’s Plan A, which was to create the SNC [Syrian National Council], went down in dust. By all accounts, Clinton cannot even stand to hear the name, SNC, uttered any longer.

Plan B was to set up the US office in Istanbul to meet and take the measure of Syrian militia leaders and local co-ordinating committee directors. The militia leaders scared Washington and the CIA. The word got out that they were “penetrated” by al-Qaida and Salafi types.

Plan C is now in the making. It is to return to the educated Syrians in the hope of doing a little shake-and-bake. Clinton is reconstituting some sort of US-friendly leadership drawn from elements of the old SNC with generous add-mixtures of Co-ordinating Committee types, some government defectors, and others who will join. It sounds as if the SNC is boycotting. Michel Kilo has said he will not join. Others are also taking a wait-and-see attitude.

The object of this exercise seems to be to glue some sort of US-friendly educated elite on to the military effort that looks too Islamist for Washington’s taste and not very human-rights observant.

Landis compares the initiative with "US and British efforts of the 1950s to stop Syria from slipping into the hands of the USSR, Nasser and the leftist Ba'athists".

Summary

Good morning. Welcome to Middle East Live. Here is a round-up of the latest developments.

Syria

Sharp disagreements have emerged at a Syrian opposition conference in Qatar meant to forge a more cohesive leadership. The Syrian National Council has balked at a plan backed by western powers that would dilute the SNC's influence. But with international pressure mounting, it also suggested it was willing to negotiate a compromise that would give it more influence in a new leadership team. The SNC is due to decide on Wednesday whether to accept a plan proposed by a prominent dissident, Riad Seif, to set up a new leadership group of about 50 members. The SNC would get about 15 seats, while military commanders and local leaders in rebel-held areas would win wider representation. SNC chief Abdelbaset Sieda said he and others in the group no longer trusted promises of international support linked to restructuring of the opposition. He said:

We faced this situation before, when we formed the SNC. There were promises like that, but the international community in fact did not give us the support needed for the SNC to do its job.

The UN-Arab League envoy to Syria, Lakhdar Brahimi, has called for a new UN security council resolution to formalise an declaration adopted in Geneva in June, which called for a transitional administration but did not specify what role, if any, Assad would take. The initiative came after Brahimi met the Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrovin Cairo yesterday. Brahimi said:

It is important that the Geneva Declaration be turned into a resolution from the security council to gain the power to enable it to become an applicable political project.

Al-Jazeera reported that Lavrov dismissed the need for a resolution, saying “some countries which participated in Geneva don't speak with the government but only with the opposition and encourage them to fight till victory and this has very negative implications”.

The Syrian army has bombarded rebel strongholds in southern Damascus on Monday with artillery and from the air, hours after opposition fighters attacked militia loyal to President Bashar al-Assad, opposition activists told Reuters. Warplanes fired rockets and tanks and artillery pounded the neighbourhoods of Sbeineh, Yalda, Bibla, al-Tadamun and Hajar a-Aswad, they said. The working-class Sunni Muslim neighbourhoods have been at the forefront of the 19-month-old revolt against Assad

Japan is to host international talks in late November aimed at widening sanctions against Syria, it said today.Existing sanctions include freezing assets of the Syrian president and military leaders and an embargo on oil and arms trade with Syria.

Syrian rebels captured an oilfield in the east of the country on Sunday after three days of fierce fighting with government troops protecting the facility, activists said. The head of the Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, Rami Abdul-Rahman, said rebels overran the al-Ward oilfield in the province of Deir el-Zour near the border with Iraq. About 40 soldiers were guarding the facility that the rebels had been pounding for the past three days, he said, adding that opposition fighters also captured several regime troops.

Kuwait

Kuwaiti security forces have fired teargas to disperse a banned demonstration by about 2,000 opposition supporters against new voting rules for parliamentary elections due on 1 December. The emir announced changes to the electoral law last month which some opposition politicians say are an attempt to give pro-government candidates an advantage in the polls.

Libya

Comments (…)

Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion

Most viewed

Most viewed