Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to navigation
Children wait to get vaccinated at a health clinic in Apia, Samoa.
Children wait to get vaccinated at a health clinic in Apia, Samoa. The Otago Daily Times ran a cartoon making light of the epidemic that has killed more than 50 people. Photograph: AP
Children wait to get vaccinated at a health clinic in Apia, Samoa. The Otago Daily Times ran a cartoon making light of the epidemic that has killed more than 50 people. Photograph: AP

New Zealand newspaper publishes cartoon mocking Samoa measles crisis

This article is more than 4 years old

Otago Daily Times criticised for cartoon joking about measles outbreak that has killed 55

A New Zealand newspaper has caused outrage for publishing a cartoon that made light of the measles crisis engulfing Samoa, which has killed 55 people so far, most of them children under the age of four.

The Otago Daily Times published the cartoon in Tuesday’s newspaper from artist Garrick Tremain, which depicted two white women walking out of a travel agent, one saying to the other: “I asked ‘What are the least popular spots at the moment?’ She said: ‘The ones people are picking up in Samoa.’”

The newspaper issued an apology on Tuesday afternoon, saying, “The content and timing of the cartoon were insensitive, and we apologise without reservation for publishing it.”

Samoa has been gripped by a devastating measles outbreak over the past six weeks. There have been almost 4,000 confirmed cases in a country of just 200,000 people and 55 people have died, 50 of them children under four.

50 babies picked up those spots and died, Otago Daily Times. pic.twitter.com/lrQLScR9ow

— Sita Leota (@SitaLeota) December 3, 2019

The paper’s editor, Barry Stewart, added in the apology that he would review the paper’s selection process for cartoons.

Stewart acknowledged the outbreak meant people were suffering “real hurt and real tragedy”.

“This should have been our starting point when considering publishing the cartoon. That it was not was a deeply regrettable error in judgment,” he wrote.

The cartoon provoked outrage on Twitter.

A New Zealand journalist, Michael Field, who has an written a book on Samoa, called the paper “nasty and cruel”.

“They have a cartoon that mocks Samoa for its pain. What other newspaper would laugh at dead children?” he wrote.

Anna Powles, a senior lecturer in Pacific security at Massey University in New Zealand, wrote that the newspaper had only issued a “half-baked apology” for what was a “disgraceful” and “absolutely abhorrent” cartoon.

  • This article was amended on 3 December 2019 to correct the name of the cartoonist, who was previously identified as Chris Tremain.

Most viewed

Most viewed